|
Pessimistic
Scenario
Expectations:
Oil production is
already peaking or will reach its peak within four years. After oil production
begins to drop even enormous efforts to drill and produce more oil will
not be able counteract the depletion of the worlds largest oil fields.
The result will be rapidly increasing oil prices which will bring on worldwide
periods of depression that will draw down the energy demand just enough
to keep outright shortages from being widespread. Nonetheless a long period
of economic decline is expected eventually alleviated by new technology
and turn over to use of alternative energy sources.
Pessimists view the occurrence of peak oil to be either imminent or very
close. A turn to both non-conventional and alternative energy sources
as not being possible on a large scale in the near future and thus there
will be an unavoidable energy gap between demand and supply for the next
10-20 years.

Assumptions:
- No large oil
fields are likely to be found in the future
- Although market
forces will encourage increased spending, new oil put into production
will not be able to compensate for the depletion of old oil fields
- New technology
allows more rapid extraction of oil but will not substantially increase
the total recoverable oil from a field
- Stated reserves,
especially in the middle east are overestimates of actual recoverable
oil
- Non-conventional
oil and alternative energy sources will not be able to completely fill
the gap left by oil depletion after peak oil has occurred because the
technologies will take too long to fully implement and none replace
all the benefits of oil without their own risks.
Social and
Political consequences:
Most of the books
and articles written about "peak oil" or the coming "oil
crisis" have a basically pessimistic bottom line. All of these share
a common belief in the what they call the geological reality of peak oil.
Where they greatly differ is in their views of the effects that the oil
crisis will have on society. In some cases oil demand will result in greater
global political instability and leading to more armed conflicts. Oil
rich countries will gain greater influence while wealthy oil-poor countries
will attempt to gain control of more oil resources. Some other countries
see wealthy countries being able to dot he most with high prices alternative
energy sources thus mitigating the extreme effects of the energy crunch
but leaving developing countries such as China and India in a much more
difficult situation.
Representative
writings:
The
Coming Energy Crunch by By Aaron Naparstek. New York Press
2004. Written just before the 2004 presidential election this article
very clearly sums up what the pessimistic scenario sees as the major issues
for today's politicians.
The
World Petroleum Life-Cycle.
Richard C. Duncan and Walter Youngquist. This is a paper presented in
1998 to the Petroleum Technology Transfer Council at the University of
California. Filled with easy to understand graphics that examine when
different continents will experience peak oil production it is interesting
to compare their predictions made in 1998 to what has happened in these
locations since. A .pdf version of this paper can be bound HERE.
The
Ugly Oil Supply Scenario by Glenn Morton. Written in 2002
Morton presents an overall picture of the evidence for peak oil and a
picture of how an oil crisis might play out within this decade. Slightly
outdated data now but Morton is an insider in the oil industry and so
does have an interesting perspective. As with Campbell below, some aspects
of Morton's view fit with the Head for the Hills
Scenario.
The
Peak Oil Debate: Crisis or Comedy by Matthew Simmons. PDF
version of a presentation given at a conference in September 2004 by energy
industry investment banker Matt Simmons.
Simmons has been a leading advocate of the dangers of peak
oil. He runs one of the largest investment firms that specializes in financing
the energy industry and has served Vice President Dick Cheney's energy
panel.
Peak
Oil: an outlook on crude oil depletion by
C. J. Campbell revised 2002. Campbell is the father figure of the coming
oil crisis advocates. He has written and lectured extensively on the topic
and is the most widely quoted individual in the debate. His book "The
Coming Energy Crisis" is a must read for those that want to understand
the peak oil position. Here we characterize his position in the "Pessimistic
Scenario" but many aspects of his writings would place him as comfortably
in the Head for the Hills Scenario.
Web pages of interest:
Oil
Depletion Analysis Center (ODAC): is
an independent, UK-registered educational charity working to raise international
public awareness and promote better understanding of the world's oil-depletion
problem. A simple, well organized, informative web site.
Association
for the Study of Peak Oil (ASPO): Most complete web site
representing a peak oil view. Founded by the accepted leader of the peak
oil movement, Colin Campbell. The monthly newsletter are filled with a
large amount of industry data and analysis.
The
DryDipstick: A
metadirectory for peak oil that contains a huge number of links to current
articles on peak oil and other oil data.
PeakOil.com:
A news and message boards site where members post articles and information,
on a daily basis, that bears on the oil depletion debate. This is a good
place to go to see the most current discussion usually from pro-peak oil
point of view.
Glenn
Morton's Oil Crisis Page: This site has a number of writings
by an industry insider who examines some of the data on oil production
and directly addresses many of the assumptions of the oil optimists.
Book length treatises:
Hubbert's
Peak: The impending world oil shortage by K Deffeyes
(2001) Professor Emeritus Princeton University. A very good introduction
to the the oil industry covering basic aspects of how oil is found and
extracted. With the necessary background Deffeyes then explores Hubbert's
historical projects and assesses whether his approach can be applied at
a global scale. This book is both helpful to a novice to the oil question
but also provides enough novel insight that it would be helpful to even
those that are quite familiar with the basic concepts. A follow-up book,
Beyond
Oil goes "beyond" his first book and looks
at possible scenarios for how the world enery scene will play out.
The
Coming Oil Crisis by C. J. Campbell (2004). The most
comprehensive overview of the peak oil position written by a true believer.
|